John considered her the glue that held them together. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. In contrast to the Duttons Salem origins, they continued, ranch manager Rip Wheeler (Cole Hauser) could also have some surprising roots. Most of her mentality and mental issues definitely stem from her mother and her mothers death in her environment, she was bound to be a little tougher, growing up on a ranch and having three brothers and a dozen ranch hands influencing the way you think and talk, her mother was probably one of her few gateways into femininity. Kayce left to be with Monica when she got pregnant with Tate and was branded out of spite by John. Some fans, however, still dont think enough has been said on the matter. That's one helluva thing to bestow upon a young girl. Because she hates herself???. In a flashback episode in Yellowstone season 2, we see John Dutton Sr. (Dabney Coleman) as the young John Duttons father in 1883. This supposed matriarch that John has been pining away for or Beth cant get over, sure seemed kind of insensitive and spiteful. ---- The Yellowstone episode No Good Horses explains what happened to her. Y:1883 will premiere December 19, 2021 on Paramount+. So sad. I dont agree with it and the scene of falling off the horse could have been a moment Of compassion between mother and daughter but it shows how tough this woman really was. Will miss when the series ends ! Even so, their explanation could provide some valuable insight into the reasoning behind Evelyns hatred of her own child. Redditor iheartsev agrees that Beths mother seemed way too nasty b****y to her during that last ride with Kayce and Beth. Who knows. And we know Rip has no qualms about absolutely wrecking people for much . People are always saying things like Beth would've made a great cowboy because of how tough she is. Jamies biological father was sent to prison for the murder of his mother. 'Yellowstone': What Happened to John Dutton's Wife? It is known that Beth keeps her sterility from everyone, and it remains the seething secret that understandably destroys her and Jamies relationship forever. In Yellowstone Season 3, John finally learns the truth amid Beth and Jamies ever-escalating feud. Introducing Evelyn Dutton (played by Gretchen Mol) via flashback, in the final moments before a fatal riding accident, reframes a lot of what the audience understood about the Dutton family.. This theory could be too much for some viewers to wrap their heads around, but they can tune into the new series this December to find out whether or not it holds water. Monica Long was married to Kayce and they had a son named Tate. William Armstrong is a senior editor with H-O-M-E.org, where he writes on a wide variety of topics. She has more chemistry with him than summer. Doesnt really make sense. Yellowstone is available to stream on Philo and Peacock. This explanation makes sense to me. However, this approach backfired, and resulted in Beths mother gettng crushed by a horse. Evelyn and her sisters are the mothers of Jamie and Jimmy. For all of Beths worship of her father, John Dutton is not (nor has he ever been) known for Danny Tanner-level heart-to-hearts. Things have arguably grown even more acidic between the siblings in Season 2, with Beth's constant barrage . When she falls, Kayce stays by Evelyns side while Beth rushes off to call for help. Why was Evelyn Dutton so mean to Beth? We're firmly in a hiatus of Dutton family dramathe fifth (super-sized) season of Yellowstone is set to return with more (hopefully not final) episodes this summer, while the new prequel series 1923 is officially coming back for a second seasonbut that doesn't mean our minds aren't still on . And why Beth is the way she is. I do feel bad for this whole families tragedy due to the death of their mother & wife ! Season 3 of Yellowstone continued with "Cowboys and Dreamers," which aired on Sunday, July 19. Yellowstone Wiki is a FANDOM TV Community. About halfway through their meal, John's . Categories . And for that, we cant fault Yellowstones writers at all. In season 1, episode 7, The Long Black Day, we see a flashback to the day that Evelyn died. Beth was able to escape the burning building, but she was left with severe burns on her face. The beginning of episode three of the first season of Yellowstone brings us our first flashback, during which we learn how Beth developed that chip on her shoulder, and boy is it ever a doozy. Jamie may have had his moments of revenge, but those stories have all fallen apart. Fans are now reflecting on the characters relationship and the negative impact her mother has on her. No wonder Beth is a mess.. He lost his adoptive mother at a young age. If youre as invested in Yellowstone as we are, then you already know about Beth Duttons rocky relationship with her late mother. Yellowstone plot hole: Why doesn't the Dutton's home have security? Beth is noticeably terrified of the animal. He was placed in the line of fire by his attacker. My best guess is and I've said it before perhaps Evelyn and John only wanted boys instead of girls, and Evelyn resented having Beth. 15 Facts About Evelyn Dutton Yellowstone, 14 Facts About Jacob Elordi Movies And Tv Shows. Evelyn Dutton is the biological mother of Lee, Kayce, and Beth Dutton. No wonder Beth is a mess. Yellowstone fans are coming to the Dutton daughters defense after re-watching flashbacks with her mother, Evelyn. Columbia, South Carolina, United States of America, is home to an American actress namedKelsey Asbille Chow. The latter is without Beths knowledge and consent. This is how she dies. John Dutton Sr. was a great role model for his son and helped him bcome the man he is today. Beths mom wanted to toughen her up. Yellowstone Season 5 | "Why Is Beth Dutton So Mean?" Explained Im not a horse expert, but ive been around them a fair amount. Yellowstone season 4: Garrett Randall's wife related to Evelyn Dutton. He cant get a marriage license at the courthouse because he doesnt have a birth certificate. Was there something I missed that sheds light on this? Fans of Yellowstone discuss in a post why John favors Kayce over Jamie. why was evelyn dutton so mean to beth why was evelyn dutton so mean to beth. The details of the accident are not clear, but it seems that Beths horse became spooked and threw her off, causing her mother to be fatally crushed by another horse. Evelyn Dutton | Yellowstone Wiki | Fandom How did a teenage Beth manage the hormonal changes of a hysterectomy? According to Beth, the best of her father died along with her mother. Enough for some viewers to speculate that she hates her daughter. She wasnt strong enough in the horse to lead it confidently. Jamies goal in this scenario is two-fold. Evelyn Dutton. Jamie is not gleeful at the prospect, far from it. Christina told Jamie that he did exactly what he said he was going to do. Jamie came up with the idea of having Beth get an abortion at the Indian Reservation in order to keep this from John. All too true. I Lov this series Yellowstone its actresses & actors! He never has been fully able to recover from her tragic death. This side shows shes perhaps just trying to teach Beth about the tougher side of living on a ranch rather than just ragging on her for no reason. In Yellowstone Season 5, Beth tells Monica she has always been mean. Evelyns monologue arguably sets in Beths mind that it is her against the world. The hit series Yellowstone follows the Dutton family as they fight to defend their highly sought-after land. While working as an actress in Los Angeles, Reilly said she would visit places like Montana, Colorado . But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. Evelyn has briefly appeared throughout the series as a cold-hearted parent to her and John Duttons (Kevin Costner) only daughter. It was a time when Beth was a skittish young teen with no self-confidence , which irritated her mother Evelyn (Gretchen Mol). You can unsubscribe at any time. 4 Facts About Luke Grimess Wife, I would like to see John Dutton with his secretary. This is a full explai. Evelyn says that everything will change for Beth starting that day. An experienced horse woman reacting so swiftly to basically blame her own child, knowing she was pretty much going to die because she was broken and miles from help, shes either a crazy person or she actually had real hate in her heart for Beth. Now because of that, Evelyn says she'll be harder on her so that she can turn Beth into something that most men will never be. Yeah but Beth had zero confidence riding the horse. What is the reason for Kayce to be branded? Evelyn nver came to know her grandson as she died when she was out horse riding on March 30, 1997. I think her mom loved her but wanted to make her strong in the town of ranchers and men. and Im sorry in advance for doing it. She feels guilty about the accident and, at one point, even believes that she killed her mother by being scared when they went horseback riding that time. Yellowstone: Why Does Beth Hate Jamie So Hard? | Cinemablend The Great Yellowstone Rewatch: S1 E3: "No Good Horses" Beth is being raised on a really large Montana ranch. Bottom lineif someone stole your Rip, youd be a b***h too.. She only makes four appearances in Yellowstone, as she passed away in 1997 when her children were still young. Beths final moments with her mother were not filled with forgiveness or comfort. One would tell her to tell him. She is treating Beth with such disdain because she knows Beth will end up with Rip.. Evelyn is a comforting mother as Beth sits in the bathtub, but she has some more tough words of wisdom for her daughter. Her mother clearly blames Beth for her impending death and makes no bones about it. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. I know she's a very popular character, but I feel like she just sucks up the atmosphere on the show. Now that we have addressed that, there is another plot point Yellowstone has ignored. 'The Father Who Moves Mountains' Ending, Explained: Let's Discuss, 'Mystery 101' Update: Why I'm Worried About The Next Movie, 'Money Heist' Series Ending, Explained: How Season 5 Finished It All. As for Beth, she gets traumatized by the incident and the harsh dying words of her mother. I mean come on even moms love their sons. How Did Beth's Mother Die On Yellowstone? - Toyseen Evelyn even said something to Beth the day the young girl got her first period. However, she was also fiercely independent and stubborn, which led to some tension between her and John. 1923 Series Premiere Reveals The Brutal Way Margaret Dutton Died However, that doesnt seem to be the case at all. She continues to wrestle with what ifs, self-loathing, guilt, and the weight of keeping her biggest truth from Rip. The brothers were angry with Beth for firing their father, so they set fire to the Dutton Ranchs barn. Upon her tragic fall, Beth rushed off to get help, and Kayce stayed at her side. Yellowstone: Hidden meaning in Beth Dutton's scars exposed | TV & Radio Her horse got spooked and fell on her while she was out riding with Beth and Kayce. Evelyn Dutton takes her last breath when John reaches her. But he will be mad at Jamie. During that time, Evelyn looks at Beth and says, She did this. John Duttons wife Evelyn Dutton died in a horseback riding accident on March 30, 1997. Jamies relationship with the family was complicated by the fact that he is the adopted son of John. That whole scenario still seems so out of place to me, they cite, calling it jarring., Thats an excellent one-word description of the flashback, to be sure. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. The show has plenty of enigmatic characters, and one that has fans debating is Evelyn Dutton, John Duttons wife. Nope. Evelyn Dutton died when her children were still young. So, what have we learned about why Beth is so mean? The show has told us that she pushed Rip away and engaged in every endeavor to do that. Evelyn then apologizes to her in advance, saying she will hate everything thats about to happen to her. The fourth season of Yellowstone is well on its way, and viewers are still none the wiser to the fate of Beth Dutton (played by Kelly Reilly) after last years staggering finale. This post may contain affiliate links. Beth Dutton received her scar on her face during an attack orchestrated by the Beck brothers. Now, an extreme event like that is just that, a freak event. It obviously wasnt the warmest or cuddliest of moms but I think she was taking care of Beth the best she knew how, maybe how she was raised? Jamie has two brothers and a sister, and he is the son of John and Evelyn Dutton. Theyve Had an Inappropriate Relationship For Months, How Black Creators Can Expand Their Network with LinkedIn. Jamie met his child for the first time. Evelyn Dutton died after getting crushed by her horse after the horse got frightened and both fell over. It is a burning question on so many #yellowstone viewers' minds. UX Design Portfolio. In one episode, during Evelyns death anniversary, Beth, struggling to cope, bathed in a trough and drank champagne to wash away her guilt. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. Yellowstone fans found out in season 3 that Jamie was adopted by John and Evelyn Dutton when he was just three months old. Related: Is Yellowstone Based on a True Story? 'Yellowstone': Fans Debate Whether Evelyn Dutton Was Too Hard on Beth After falling off, Evelyn says, while looking at Beth, She did this. John Dutton and Jamies mother were atually cousins. She told the 10 year old that it was her fault if she died because she loved Kayce the most. She . The Dutton Family Tree, Explained - sg.finance.yahoo.com 'Yellowstone': Every Question Fans Need Answered In Season 4 A longstanding sibling . Beth is mean due to a mixture of many tragic layers, further amplified by her ongoing fury regarding her most unquenched desire. why was evelyn dutton so mean to beth When she was younger, she was unable to have a baby because Jamie took her to a clinic that left her infertile. She wasn't born tough, she was made tough. In Season 1 Episode 8, we learn that Rip's stepdad killed his mom. Since the start of "Yellowstone," there have been so many products and posts dedicated to this character. But Beth got a raw deal from mommy dearest, one Reddit user writes in response to the original poster. Evelyn passed away a few hours after she did not die immediately. We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you've consented to and to improve our understanding of you. Creedence Clearwater Revivals Have You Ever Seen The Rain Gives A Glimpse Before The Bands Split, 10 Popular Country Songs That Were Originally Cover Hits, 18 Best Country Songs About Best Friends to Add to Your Playlist, 15 Best Country Songs About Faith To Build Your Confidence In God And His Word, 25 Best Country Songs About Home and Hometowns You Should Listen To, Here Are the 15 Best Country Songs About Working Hard To Keep You Motivated. RELATED: The Cast of Yellowstone and Where You Mightve Seen Them Before. Snowflakes are complainers and have an entitlement complex. Beths mom being cold af in her dying moments was fucked, but ultimately it finished the job of making Beth tougher than any man. Kevin has always stated that Evelyn was the love of Johns life and even created a song just for her on his Tales from the Yellowstone album, so clearly there was a very deep love and her loss impacted them all very deeply. John Dutton Sr. was a prominent figure in the area and had a lot of influence over his son. Feeling mixed emotions for the remainder of her days, Beth struggles with being blamed for the death and how she never got closure with her mom. Our readers support us. Beth's unstable emotional state is a result of multiple factors, with her mother being only a piece of the puzzle. When the horse fell on her she straight up told a 10 year old that it was her fault if she died, while basically saying that Kayce was the child she loved most. Eclectic Pop has a spinoff! While riding a horse with her mother and brother, Beth's hesitation resulted in her mom landing hard on the ground and getting crushed by one of the animals. Rip loves Beth dearly, and he won't be mad at her when he finds out the truth of what happened. The story goes that. Jamie helped Beth procure an abortion after she decided to end her pregnancies. Lee Dutton. However, he has not remarried yet or had a serious relationship. Yellowstone Season 2. Riggins was the man who hired the militia to attack John, Kayce and Beth, as well as the ranch, but his motives are not known. There is no way to recover from that massive of a procedure privately. However, her life forever changed on March 30, 1997. But we see flashbacks mostly from beths perspective which taints the memory. Family relationships and dynamics are tough in reality And not many of us have a family with standing practice of dealing with disagreements with the train station.